Jared Casper at AutoFair Subaru
Tips for Selling Your Car Privately | Learn with subaru.fmycar.com

8 Expert Tips for Selling Your Car Privately

Published: July 21, 2025 | By: Jared Casper | Categories: Vehicle Information, Car Selling Tips

Selling your car privately can put more cash in your pocket—but it also requires more effort than trading it in. Follow these eight expert tips to prepare, market, and close your private sale smoothly and safely.

1. Thoroughly Prepare Your Vehicle

First impressions matter. Invest in a professional detail or spend an afternoon cleaning inside and out. Fix minor blemishes like stone chips or scratches, ensure fluids are topped off, and replace any burnt‑out bulbs. A well‑presented car attracts more serious buyers.

2. Research and Set the Right Price

Use trusted valuation tools—Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds, and local classifieds—to gauge fair market value. Price slightly above your bottom line to leave room for negotiation but avoid overpricing, which can deter inquiries.

3. Craft a Compelling Listing

Your ad should include:

  • Clear, honest description of mileage, condition, service history, and upgrades
  • Vehicle VIN and service record highlights
  • Contact preferences and availability

4. Take High‑Quality Photos

Photograph your car in natural light from multiple angles: front, sides, rear, interior, engine bay, and trunk. A smartphone with HDR turned on is sufficient—just keep the lens clean and shoot against a neutral backdrop.

5. Advertise Strategically

Post your listing on high‑traffic platforms like Autotrader, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace. Share on local community groups and ask friends to repost. The wider the reach, the better your chances of finding the right buyer quickly.

6. Screen Potential Buyers

Pre‑qualify interested parties by phone before scheduling viewings. Ask about their budget, financing, and experience buying used cars. This filters out casual lookers and helps ensure a serious inquiry when they arrive.

7. Conduct Safe Test Drives

Meet in a public, well‑lit location and accompany the buyer on the drive. Verify their driver's license and insurance before handing over keys. Limit test drives to familiar routes and maintain control throughout.

8. Finalize Paperwork Professionally

Prepare all necessary documents in advance: title transfer forms, bill of sale, and release of liability. Accept secure payment—preferably cashier’s check or electronic transfer—and complete the title transfer at your DMV.

Got Questions?

If you need personalized guidance or want to explore dealer trade‑in options, contact our team. We’re here to help you choose the path that gets you the most value.